The Long Blue Line: Saving Sunbeam—a deadly human trafficking case over 100 years ago

By Capt. Daniel A. Laliberte, United States Coast Guard retired


It was early on the cold, windy The Coast Guard Cutter Manning was a 205-foot, 1,155-ton “cruising cutter,” designed for the sea keeping qualities required to perform offshore rescues under severe weather conditions. ( of Wednesday, Dec. 17, 1919. The Coast Guard Cutter Manning commenced a slow, measured approach to the disabled schooner Sunbeam, adrift 150 miles off the Virginia Capes. Before the cutter was in position to shoot a messenger line across the schooner’s forecastle as the lead for a heavier towing hawser, Manning’s captain, Andrew Henderson noticed the wallowing schooner appeared to be settling in the water. To his astonishment, the schooner rolled over within minutes and disappeared beneath the surface. Flotsam, a single lifeboat with two people aboard, and around half-a-dozen men thrashing in the frigid waters were the only evidence that the vessel had ever been there.

Two of the seven people rescued that morning turned out to be Chinese “stowaways.”  Subsequent debriefings of the survivors revealed that in addition to the schooner’s seven crewmembers, 18 Chinese people had been aboard, strongly suggesting that this voyage had been a smuggling venture.

Smuggling Chinese non-citizens into the United States began soon after the Chinese Exclusion Act of 1882 severely restricted the legal entry of Chinese people into the country. Smuggling ventures were initially concentrated on the West Coast, with a maritime route from the city of Victoria, in Vancouver, Canada, to Washington State. However, pressure from the Revenue Cutter Service—forerunner of the Coast Guard—and the Customs Service, soon encouraged illegal migration east along the land border with Canada and south to Mexico.After World War I, the Navy returned the Coast Guard Cutter Manning to the jurisdiction of the Coast Guard, which stationed it in Norfolk, Virginia.  The cutter was assigned to annual “winter cruising” from December through March each year. (

Smuggling Chinese migrants continued for decades then virtually disappeared during World War I. However, the U.S. Commissioner General of Immigration reported ominous indications of a resumption after the war. In early 1919, 3,000 Chinese legally transited the U.S. to Cuba. Although they were ostensibly doing so to take advantage of one-year employment contracts there, the Commissioner General believed they were only the vanguard of a growing number that would take advantage of this loophole to find a back door into the U.S.

History would prove the Commissioner General right. By 1921, more than 30,000 young Chinese men resided in Cuba. Almost all of them were believed to be awaiting a clandestine passage to the U.S. for a fee ranging from $500 to $1,000 each.

A small percentage of those trying to enter the U.S. by sea were true stowaways or deserting seaman, but the vast majority were smuggled. Some were moved individually, or in small groups, usually aboard large commercial vessels with the complicity of crewmembers. Others were smuggled in groups of 15 to 20 from Havana, often aboard sailing vessels like Sunbeam, which would emerge as the center of non-citizen smuggling to the U.S.

Crewmembers of the Coast Guard Cutter Manning take a break from “coaling ship” in 1926.  The Manning was built in 1898 at a time when coal-fired steam plants were still the major source of maritime propulsion. (, the Sunbeam departed Havana, Cuba, in late November 1919. The three-masted, 137-ton schooner was bound for New York with a declared cargo of molasses. Its master, a “Captain Rivera,” reported as “Riveron” by the newspapers, would later claim that he discovered the 18 undeclared Chinese people concealed on board only after already underway. This was a common defense, and often successful given the burden of proof necessary to establish intent. On the 18th day of its voyage, a passing steamer reported via radio that the schooner was disabled. Sunbeam’s sails had been shredded by a gale, but it was not in immediate danger.

Moored at its homeport of Norfolk, Virginia, Coast Guard Cutter Manning soon got underway to assist. The Manning was built in 1898 for the Coast Guard’s predecessor service, the Revenue Cutter Service. Although a relic of the age of coal-fired steam propulsion, the 205-foot, 1,155-ton, twin-screw “cruising cutter” had been designed for sea keeping qualities. The cutter and its crews were detailed twice to the Navy—during the Spanish American War and, more recently, during World War I.

Having returned to the Coast Guard only four months earlier, the Manning was assigned the “Winter Cruising” mission for the area bounded to the north by Great Egg Harbor, New Jersey, and to the south by Cape Hatteras, North Carolina. From December through March, the cutter was required to continuously patrol offshore, “keeping at all times a vigilant lookout for vessels in need of assistance, except for brief stops for logistics or maintenance.” Under the command of Capt. Henderson, who had served nearly 15 years at sea—five of them in command of cutters—the Manning was ideally suited for rescue at sea in the worst weather conditions.

The Manning received a radio call at mid-morning on the 16th from the steamer Chicomico. The Chicomico passed an updated position and reported that it had taken the Sunbeam in tow, but requested that the cutter relieve them. Less than four hours later, the Manning arrived on scene. In spite of heavy winds and high seas, the Sunbeam appeared seaworthy, so Henderson decided to take the schooner in tow without first conducting a boarding. Establishing the tow went well, but the heavy winds and rising seas limited towing speed to little more than steerage.Cutter Manning prepares to shoot a messenger line to a disabled three-masted schooner. The messenger line was used to haul a heavy towing hawser from the cutter to the disabled vessel. (

During the night, the towline parted and the cutter stood by, monitoring the Sunbeam by searchlight, waiting for morning to reestablish the tow. At first light, the cutter sought to reestablish the tow, but the schooner sank suddenly and inexplicably.

With only minutes to pull the survivors from the water before hypothermia killed them, the Manning quickly hoisted the two men from the lifeboat and smoothly transitioned from towing operations to water rescue. Since the high seas and near gale-force winds ruled out launching his own boats, Henderson backed and filled the cutter to an upwind position, then drifted down onto the debris field. His crew deployed two rafts and several life buoys, which four men were able to crawl onto or cling to, before hauling them aboard the cutter.

By this time, two men remaining in the water became unresponsive and unable to assist in their own rescue. Warrant Boatswain Albert Hays and Seaman Jens Krestensen were lowered from the forecastle to retrieve them. Several times during the descent, they had to use their hands and feet to fend themselves from smashing against the cutter’s hull as it rolled in heavy seas. When safely in the water, they quickly swam to the unconscious men, untangled them from the debris, attached lifelines to them, and shielded them as they were lifted aboard the cutter. Once on deck, other Coast Guardsmen commenced “resuscitation treatment,” now known as rescue breathing, and were able to revive one of the two men. For their acts of heroism, Hays and Krestenson were awarded citations by the Coast Guard.

The rescue of the survivors of the Sunbeam demonstrated seamanship and heroism that has become a hallmark of the Coast Guard. The event also revealed the start of renewed non-citizen smuggling to the U.S. Throughout Prohibition, traffickers would continue to move Chinese migrants by sea from both Mexico and Cuba to the East Coast until World War II, when Chinese immigration policies were relaxed.

Image Gallery

1 - 12 of 17 results
CGD 24 Wainwright Unknown port; photo taken from quarterdeck of unnamed USCG cutter. Boston? Photo...
USCG patrol boats during Prohibition
"Coast Guard Destroyer Downes (From a Painting by the Destroyer Force Bugle Staff Artist, Marius...
"Ensign Roland making end run, Coast Guard-Marine game, Washington, D.C., 1929." Scanned from...
"1929 - Coast Guard Football Team - 1929. Back Row: -Lieut. Baker, Coast and Manager; Wineke,...
A photo of Coast Guard Destroyer CONYNGHAM on patrol during Prohibition.
Coast Guard Destroyer's baseball team (no date).
Hand-written caption on reverse of photo reads: "Officers and crew of CGC Beale (Navy destroyer...
Hand-written caption on reverse of photo reads: "R R Waesche Sr., CGC Snohomish, Port Angeles, or...
"BEALE (CG-9) (Of the old U.S. Coast Guard Destroyer Force - 1924-1930) An early 20th century...
"Engineroom Force of the Coast Guard Cutter PONTCHARTRAIN. 3-5-29 (1)." CCG Scrapbook (CG...
Copy photo found in the CG Historian's Office Special Collections Archive in the "Uniforms" folder....

U.S. Coast Guard Historian's Office
2703 Martin Luther King, Jr., Ave, SE
Washington, DC 20593-7031

U.S. Coast Guard Museum
Coast Guard Academy - Waesche Hall
15 Mohegan Ave
New London, CT 06320-8100

Contacting us:  U.S.C.G. Historian's Office